Sep 20, 2019 at 7: 13 pm

Why Superclusters Matter



In recent months, Innovation Superclusters has become a more frequent topic. Recent keynotes have brought up the need for European Superclusters. Several conferences, including the upcoming Global Peter Drucker Forum is now running special tracks on Innovation Superclusters.

Just returning from the Transylvanian Cluster Conference, we caught up with author of Building Innovation Superclusters, Mr. Christian Rangen, for a short update.

Chris, you have become a vocal advocate for what you call Innovation Superclusters. Perhaps you can shed some light on why you think we need these Superclusters?


Yes, of course. So the answer is really simple; Europe is falling behind – and we need to catch up. I deeply believe Superclusters is a big part of that solution in the coming years.

Let us look at US, China and Europe, arguably the top three economic blocks. Across many key metrics, Europe is already lagging and falling further and further behind. Take the 25 largest tech companies in the world, none of these are European. Not one.

Let’s look at high-growth companies; China has 125, the US has 191, Europe has 41. Company valuations, access to early-stage and growth capital, maturity and quality of entrepreneurial ecosystems, spending on research & development, new patents in key fields like AI, access to data, value capture for investors; Europe is falling behind in all of these. Now, it is not that Europe isn’t innovating; of course it is. It is just that our competition is innovating so much faster. If that trend continues over the next decade, we are going to have a massive problem on our hands, or perhaps we already have?

It is against this backdrop I believe we need to develop an entirely new paradigm around our cluster thinking. It really is a paradigm shift. Today we have around 3000 clusters in Europe. I am not convinced this is the best path to continue on. Rather, I would hope to see visionary leaders – government, industry or entrepreneurial – come together and lay out a roadmap for a few top, truly elite Superclusters. We frequently talk about elite or leading universities, let’s do the same thing for clusters. Let’s decide to lead in a number of key future industries, not only through research, but through company building, talent development, new venture vehicles, corporate transformations and bold leadership. These are the tasks of clusters. Let’s upgrade them, get more visionary leaders in place and start building the clusters that will become Europe’s key engines of future economic growth. It can be done. We know how to do it.

At some levels, the movement is already happening. The movement around Clusters of Change is building, running the world’s first Cluster Accelerator Program in Frankfurt. This is a superb contribution to changing how we think, plan and build clusters in Europe and beyond.

Right, so in your definition, what are Innovation Superclusters?


In our recent report, we lay out the Three Types of Clusters we see. These are Emerging Cluster, Growth Cluster and Supercluster. There are several distinct traits that make a Supercluster stand out.

First of all, they stretch beyond any one local region. Easily, they have roots and members in various regions or countries. Second, they are large in terms of members, programs and impact. Third, they have access to funding and business models that allow for a financially sustainable cluster. Forth, and that is really the key, they go beyond the Triple Helix and connect startups, scale-ups, accelerators, investors, angels and VC funds deeply into the network and community of a cluster. Finally, true Superclusters really become magnets, drawing in the very best talent, capital and companies in the world, because this is really where it is happening.

Now, if we simplify things, a Supercluster is really all about impact and value creation. That’s it.

In a recent interview, I believe you said “Superclusters is nothing new”. This caught some attention. Perhaps you could expand on this?


That is correct, I did mention that. So this is an interesting misunderstanding perhaps.
The term Supercluster has been around in the research, in the literature for at least 20 years, quite possibly far longer. You can go back to some of the original cluster research, and you will see the term being used quite naturally.

For some reasons, it did not catch on or simply remained dormant.

Today, you can find very interesting research sources both mentioning and discussing Superclusters. I think it is very important for us to connect the past to the present and future initiatives on building Innovation Superclusters.

Based on your recent work and research, what is your outlook for Superclusters in the coming decades?


Yeah, so that is a great question. In the report we do write that we will see a number of new Supercluster initiatives toward 2030. Today, I believe we will see even more than I was first predicting.

I think developing economies see the attraction and value in ecosystems like San Francisco, Tel Aviv and London. But rather than developing ecosystems, which by their very nature and definition is very hard to develop, many of these governments and leaders will say, “wait a minute. What we need next is a massive cluster or even Supercluster initiative”. I hear many if these conversations and we expect to hear many more.

For Europe, I think there are already early conversations underway, I would really hope and expect that these lead to a series of EU-based Supercluster initiatives.

You just returned from the Transylvanian Cluster Conference, what were some of your observations?


First of all, the conference itself was very well organized and run. There were some fantastic people and very warm and inclusive culture. It was my first time in Cluj, and I really appreciated that.

My biggest observation was probably the “heroes” I met. Cluster managers and formal cluster leaders described a large set of challenges, financially, culturally, competencies, around clusters. I really see these guys, building successful clusters on a daily basis as heroes.

Second, I see exactly the same challenges in the Romanian clusters as in most places I work with around the world. A need for more success stories, better cluster alignment, the incredible importance of the right leadership.

What I also observed was a shift in conversations and mindset. Several cluster leaders approached me to discuss, “what’s next?”. They had built an early growth cluster, with 80 – 120 members, had staff, ran projects, but they were looking for new ideas, new aspirations, and new ambitions.
For some, I suggested writing a Future Vision 2030 story. For others, I urged them to go beyond the local ecosystem and bring in more international members, partners, scale-ups and simply connect better to international markets.

For some of the clusters I spoke with, I would also urge them to rethink the strong R&D focus and scientific mindset to cluster management. Let’s try a more entrepreneurial mindset for our cluster development, also in Northern Transylvania. Based on the talks I had, I absolutely believe that is going to happen.

Just to build on that, while in Transylvania, what were some of the questions you got that stuck with you?


Yeah, so just building on that, I did get a lot of questions from ecosystem people in the digital and IT space. Their questions were largely on ecosystem development, new venture building programs, accelerators and connecting to investors.

Speaking of investors, that was a big topic with many of the cluster managers I met. There was a lot of questions, but also a lot of uncertainties on how to find, how to work with and really how to be relevant to investors as an entirely new group of cluster members. These were deeply interesting and insightful conversations.

We are drawing nearer to the annual TCI event, this year in Antwerp. What are you most looking forward to and how to you think the TCI event will drive a larger conversation on Europe’s Innovation Superclusters?


Again, thank you for a great question. I have actually never been to a TCI event previously, this will be my first. So, naturally, I am looking forward to meeting like-minded people, connect to new cluster leaders and engage in deep conversations on building future-fit Innovation Superclusters. I am already meeting with a large number of European and Latin American leaders, hopefully, this will drive new mind-sets and we can all combine to drive even more visionary leadership in the global cluster space.

Specifically for building Europe’s Innovation Superclusters, I am looking forward to learning more about the on-going activities, what current leaders are already doing and who the key people are in shaping a new cluster paradigm. So, yes, I am quite excited about the upcoming TCI conference.

The annual TCI Conference takes place in Antwerp, Belgium October 8th – 10th. Learn more and sign up at the official event site.


Over the past 18 years, Chris has advised companies and governments globally on strategy, innovation, transformation and developing ecosystems. Over the past five years, he has worked extensively on Innovation Superclusters, working closely with the Malaysian and Norwegian Governments to support their national innovation programs. Chris has led multiple National Transformation Projects, including launching new accelerator programs, venture builders and early-stage VC funds. He is an active angel investor in disruptive technology firms.

Chris is also business school faculty, teaching strategy, transformation and the clean energy revolution at BI – Norwegian Business School (Norway) and Zigurat (Spain). He is an active public speaker and presents frequently at international innovation and strategy conferences




Join the conversation


  1. SexyPG1688

    SexyPG1688 uba-99thเว็บออนไลน์ที่ให้ได้มากกว่า

  2. Louann Longueville

    Hi there, I found your site by the use of Google even as searching for a similar subject, your website got here up, it appears to be like great. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

  3. cheap weed

    Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but instead of that, this is fantastic blog. An excellent read. I will certainly be back.

  4. Larryses

    cheap erectile dysfunction pills online cheapest ed pills online best pills for ed

  5. CharlesKet

    how can i get generic mobic prices: can you buy cheap mobic – buy generic mobic without dr prescription

  6. DarylWodia

    buy amoxicillin online mexico: where to buy amoxicillin 500mg without prescription

  7. BrentareLo

    where to get generic mobic without a prescription: cost cheap mobic prices – can you get mobic without rx

  8. CharlesNak

    earch our drug database.
    best male enhancement pills: treatment for ed – impotence pills
    Read information now.

  9. seller financed

    Great – I should certainly pronounce, impressed with your site. I had no trouble navigating through all tabs and related info ended up being truly easy to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Reasonably unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, website theme . a tones way for your client to communicate. Nice task..

  10. DarylWodia can i order mobic without a prescription

  11. CharlesNak

    Read now.
    buy canadian drugs maple leaf pharmacy in canada
    Prescription Drug Information, Interactions & Side.

  12. BrentareLo

    best online canadian pharmacy canada pharmacy

  13. ClaudeNossy

    generic amoxicillin over the counter buy amoxicillin 500mg online – prescription for amoxicillin

  14. Octavio Legacy

    I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own weblog and was wondering what all is needed to get set up? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny? I’m not very web savvy so I’m not 100 certain. Any suggestions or advice would be greatly appreciated. Thanks

  15. CharlesKet

    azithromycin amoxicillin antibiotic amoxicillin – amoxicillin 500mg

  16. CharlesNak

    Medscape Drugs & Diseases.
    order generic propecia price cost of cheap propecia prices
    Everything what you want to know about pills.

  17. Freddybiorn

    cheapest online pharmacy india: top online pharmacy india – top online pharmacy india

  18. Albertchank

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: medicine in mexico pharmacies – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  19. Freddybiorn

    legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy: www canadianonlinepharmacy – buying drugs from canada

  20. Albertchank

    buy prescription drugs from india: mail order pharmacy india – india online pharmacy

  21. Freddybiorn

    pharmacy rx world canada: canadian pharmacy checker – canada drugs online reviews

  22. Albertchank

    best mail order pharmacy canada: canadian pharmacy – canadian world pharmacy

  23. Albertchank

    pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: mexican mail order pharmacies – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  24. MichaelLam

    ivermectin lotion price ivermectin 1 cream ivermectin 3

  25. WilliamPydAy

    paxlovid covid: Paxlovid buy online – paxlovid price

  26. Smart Contract online Tool

    Wow! Thank you! I continually wanted to write on my website something like that. Can I include a fragment of your post to my website?

  27. RobertHAT

    canadian pharmacy review: canada drug pharmacy – canadian online pharmacy

  28. bang 4d

    bang 4d hello my website is bang 4d

  29. Ibet

    Ibet hello my website is Ibet

  30. zankyou

    zankyou hello my website is zankyou

  31. LPE88

    LPE88 hello my website is LPE88

  32. nemenin

    nemenin hello my website is nemenin

  33. BK368

    BK368 hello my website is BK368

  34. rymax

    rymax hello my website is rymax

  35. Michaelnossy

    To announce actual scoop, follow these tips:

    Look for credible sources: It’s important to safeguard that the expos‚ source you are reading is respected and unbiased. Some examples of good sources tabulate BBC, Reuters, and The Different York Times. Announce multiple sources to get back at a well-rounded aspect of a discriminating low-down event. This can support you get a more over picture and escape bias. Be in the know of the angle the article is coming from, as flush with respectable hearsay sources can be dressed bias. Fact-check the low-down with another source if a expos‚ article seems too unequalled or unbelievable. Many times make sure you are reading a advised article, as news can change quickly.

    By following these tips, you can evolve into a more in the know news reader and more intelligent be aware the beget about you.

  36. DavidDaL

    Absolutely! Declaration information portals in the UK can be awesome, but there are scads resources accessible to help you think the unexcelled identical for the sake of you. As I mentioned in advance, conducting an online search representing “UK news websites” or “British news portals” is a great starting point. Not one desire this chuck b surrender you a thorough shopping list of report websites, but it choice also lend you with a punter pact of the common hearsay prospect in the UK.
    In the good old days you be enduring a list of future story portals, it’s important to evaluate each sole to determine which richest suits your preferences. As an example, BBC Advice is known for its objective reporting of intelligence stories, while The Custodian is known quest of its in-depth opinion of governmental and group issues. The Independent is known for its investigative journalism, while The Times is known in the interest of its business and finance coverage. Not later than entente these differences, you can select the information portal that caters to your interests and provides you with the rumour you have a yen for to read.
    Additionally, it’s quality all in all local scuttlebutt portals for specific regions within the UK. These portals produce coverage of events and dirt stories that are relevant to the area, which can be exceptionally utilitarian if you’re looking to safeguard up with events in your neighbourhood pub community. In place of occurrence, local dope portals in London classify the Evening Standard and the Londonist, while Manchester Evening News and Liverpool Reproduction are hot in the North West.
    Inclusive, there are diverse news portals accessible in the UK, and it’s significant to do your inspection to see the joined that suits your needs. By means of evaluating the unalike news portals based on their coverage, luxury, and editorial perspective, you can choose the one that provides you with the most apposite and attractive info stories. Meet destiny with your search, and I anticipate this information helps you come up with the perfect dope portal since you!

  37. Francisplato

    canada online pharmacy: canadian pharmacy – pharmacy rx world canada

  38. DennisPat

    indian pharmacy paypal: mail order pharmacy india – reputable indian pharmacies

  39. JefferyVop

    top rated canadian pharmacy safe canadian pharmacy buying canadian drugs online

  40. RickeyBraig

    acheter sildenafil 100mg sans ordonnance

  41. RickeyBraig

    п»їonline apotheke: Sildenafil Preis Apotheke – versandapotheke deutschland

  42. RickeyBraig

    acheter sildenafil 100mg sans ordonnance

  43. Rogercox

    Their loyalty program offers great deals. cheapest online pharmacy india: cheapest online pharmacy india – п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india

  44. Rogercox

    Every pharmacist here is a true professional. canada drugs: canadian pharmacy – canadianpharmacyworld

  45. Michaelwrevy

    buying prescription drugs in mexico online: medicine in mexico pharmacies – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  46. EdwardJaway

    Anna Berezina is a extremely talented and famend artist, known for her unique and captivating artworks that never fail to depart an enduring impression. Her work beautifully showcase mesmerizing landscapes and vibrant nature scenes, transporting viewers to enchanting worlds filled with awe and marvel.

    What sets – Anna B. apart is her distinctive attention to detail and her remarkable mastery of shade. Each stroke of her brush is deliberate and purposeful, creating depth and dimension that bring her paintings to life. Her meticulous method to capturing the essence of her topics allows her to create truly breathtaking artistic endeavors.

    Anna finds inspiration in her travels and the fantastic thing about the natural world. She has a deep appreciation for the awe-inspiring landscapes she encounters, and this is evident in her work. Whether it’s a serene seaside at sundown, an impressive mountain vary, or a peaceful forest crammed with vibrant foliage, Anna has a exceptional capacity to seize the essence and spirit of those places.

    With a novel creative fashion that combines parts of realism and impressionism, Anna’s work is a visible feast for the eyes. Her paintings are a harmonious mix of precise details and gentle, dreamlike brushstrokes. This fusion creates a fascinating visual experience that transports viewers into a world of tranquility and sweetness.

    Anna’s expertise and artistic imaginative and prescient have earned her recognition and acclaim within the artwork world. Her work has been exhibited in prestigious galleries across the globe, attracting the eye of artwork enthusiasts and collectors alike. Each of her items has a means of resonating with viewers on a deeply personal stage, evoking emotions and sparking a way of connection with the natural world.

    As Anna continues to create beautiful artworks, she leaves an indelible mark on the world of artwork. Her capacity to capture the sweetness and essence of nature is truly outstanding, and her work function a testament to her creative prowess and unwavering ardour for her craft. Anna Berezina is an artist whose work will continue to captivate and encourage for years to come..

  47. Rogercox

    A true asset to our neighborhood. cheapest pharmacy canada: my canadian pharmacy review – online pharmacy canada

  48. Rogercox

    Efficient service with a personal touch. reputable indian online pharmacy: reputable indian pharmacies – canadian pharmacy india

  49. Michaelwrevy

    india pharmacy: india pharmacy – buy prescription drugs from india

  50. Rogercox

    The staff always ensures confidentiality and privacy. online pharmacy india: buy medicines online in india – indianpharmacy com

  51. Rogercox

    Their international drug database is unparalleled. canadian pharmacy ltd: ed meds online canada – my canadian pharmacy review

  52. Felixwag

    buy doxycycline online without prescription Doxycycline 100mg buy online doxycycline 100mg capsules cost

  53. Gregoryaledy

    Their global perspective enriches local patient care. doxycycline otc drug: buy doxycycline medicine – how to get doxycycline cheap

  54. Bobbytaw

    Their global health resources are unmatched. erectile dysfunction pills

  55. Bobbytaw

    Providing international caliber services consistently. ed pills cheap

  56. Clintloake

    They are always proactive about refills and reminders. india online pharmacy

  57. CharlesSumuh

    online pharmacy without scripts canadian pharmacy meds rx pharmacy coupons

  58. Dennisovemi

    Their health seminars are always enlightening. rx pharmacy online 24

  59. Clintloake

    Always my first choice for international pharmaceutical needs. mexican pharmaceuticals online

  60. Clintloake

    Hassle-free prescription transfers every time. buy medicines online in india

  61. Dennisovemi

    Their global reach is unmatched. best canadian pharmacy online

  62. CharlesSumuh

    online shopping pharmacy india buy medicines from India top 10 online pharmacy in india

  63. Stevendaync

    canadian mail order pharmacies: canada phamacy – cheap canadian pharmacy

  64. Jamesbit

    п»їbest mexican online pharmacies and mexico pharmacy price list – mexican drugstore online

  65. Jamesbit

    mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs and mexican pharmacy online – best online pharmacies in mexico

  66. CharlesFal

    pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa or pharmacy in mexico – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa

  67. Jamesbit

    mexican mail order pharmacies or mexico pharmacy online – purple pharmacy mexico price list

  68. RalphNit

    what is minocycline 100 mg used for: buy ivermectin canada – ivermectin 1%cream

  69. ErnieOdova

    generic valtrex online pharmacy: generic valtrex best price – purchase valtrex online

  70. ErnieOdova

    paxlovid price: buy paxlovid online – paxlovid pharmacy

  71. neoris

    It’s really a nice and useful piece of information. I’m satisfied that you shared this useful info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

  72. Terrygloth

    paxlovid cost without insurance: п»їpaxlovid – paxlovid buy

  73. Earnestmip sildenafil oral jelly 100mg kamagra

  74. DavidSoaws

    mexican mail order pharmacies: buying from online mexican pharmacy – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies

  75. Briansnafe

    buying drugs from canada: adderall canadian pharmacy – canadian pharmacy review

  76. Briansnafe

    cross border pharmacy canada: canadianpharmacymeds – canadian pharmacy victoza

  77. Briansnafe

    online shopping pharmacy india: Online medicine order – online pharmacy india

  78. Briansnafe

    ed drugs online from canada: canada drugs online – canadapharmacyonline com

  79. DavidSoaws

    canada pharmacy reviews: canada drugstore pharmacy rx – canadian pharmacy checker

  80. Briansnafe

    canadapharmacyonline com: canadian pharmacy victoza – canada pharmacy online

  81. DavidSoaws

    п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: mexico drug stores pharmacies – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  82. Briansnafe

    canadian drugs pharmacy: legit canadian pharmacy – online canadian pharmacy

  83. DavidSoaws

    safe canadian pharmacies: maple leaf pharmacy in canada – canadian drug stores

  84. Briansnafe

    online shopping pharmacy india: india pharmacy – top 10 online pharmacy in india

  85. Briansnafe

    mexican drugstore online: mexican drugstore online – buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  86. RobertGoons

    buy doxycycline without prescription: doxycycline 100mg – odering doxycycline

  87. RobertGoons

    buy cheap doxycycline online: buy doxycycline for dogs – generic for doxycycline

  88. WillieCah

    where can i get prednisone over the counter: prednisone 20 mg tablet price – prednisone 20mg tablets where to buy

  89. RobertGoons

    buy doxycycline online: buy generic doxycycline – order doxycycline online

  90. RobertGoons

    get generic propecia online: buy cheap propecia pill – cost propecia online

  91. WillieCah

    how to get cheap clomid without a prescription: order clomid price – can i buy cheap clomid without dr prescription

  92. RichardvoB

    how much is tadalafil cost of tadalafil tadalafil price

  93. RichardvoB

    cheap kamagra cheap kamagra Kamagra 100mg

  94. RichardvoB

    Buy Vardenafil online Vardenafil buy online Levitra 20 mg for sale

  95. Josephdew

    buy sildenafil from canada cheap: sildenafil paypal – sildenafil canada paypal

  96. siti web domodossola

    This design is incredible! You most certainly know how to keep a reader amused. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Excellent job. I really loved what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it. Too cool!

  97. RichardvoB

    sildenafil citrate australia sildenafil generic usa sildenafil 20 mg brand name

  98. Vernongem

    antibiotics cipro: buy ciprofloxacin online – buy ciprofloxacin over the counter

  99. Charlesjon

    zithromax antibiotic without prescription zithromax antibiotic where can you buy zithromax

  100. Charlesjon

    amoxicillin 500mg cost cheap amoxicillin amoxicillin discount coupon

  101. ScottwaynC

    zithromax for sale usa: zithromax z-pak – zithromax capsules price

  102. Vernongem

    doxycycline 20 mg: Buy doxycycline hyclate – doxycycline pharmacy singapore

  103. ScottwaynC

    can i buy zithromax over the counter in canada: buy zithromax – how to get zithromax online

  104. Charlesjon

    doxycycline 50mg tablets Buy Doxycycline for acne doxycycline without a prescription

  105. Richardpurse

    canada pharmacies without script: Mail order pharmacy – best online pharmacy reviews

  106. RobertKib

    п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: mexico pharmacy – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  107. Richardpurse

    top canadian pharmacies: buy drugs online safely – canadian drug store legit

  108. Richardpurse

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican medicine – mexican pharmaceuticals online

  109. RobertKib

    mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: mexican medicine – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  110. MichaelpHirm

    can i order clomid for sale: Clomiphene Citrate 50 Mg – where can i buy clomid without a prescription

  111. MichaelpHirm

    ventolin online united states: Ventolin inhaler online – generic ventolin

  112. MichaelpHirm

    neurontin capsules 300mg: buy gabapentin – neurontin 10 mg

  113. MichaelpHirm

    ventolin no prescription: Ventolin HFA Inhaler – ventolin 4mg tab

  114. MichaelpHirm

    order wellbutrin online from canada: buy wellbutrin – wellbutrin hcl

  115. MichaelpHirm

    can i order generic clomid without insurance: Buy Clomid Shipped From Canada – can you get cheap clomid prices

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *